Dr. Oz's Claims on Turmeric: Does He Just Make Things Up?

On an episode of the Dr. Oz Show this week, Oz claimed that an incipient study was recently relinquished that showed that Turmeric, an Indian spice, is utilizable in the treatment of irritable bowel syndrome. He recommended a dosage of 500 mg.
 
Is There Such A Human Study?
After searching for such a recent (last few years) study, I couldn't find any. In fact, a study by the title of Curcumin (Turmeric) in the Treatment of Irritable Bowel Syndrome: A Randomized-Controlled Trial (CuTIBS) was initiated in 2007, completed in 2009, and updated in 2011, but the results were never published. (see: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/results/NCT00779493). Since that time, pubmed.com, the database of clinical studies, does not identify any other such studies. Unpublished results usually mean worthless results.

A pilot study done ten years ago in 2004, contained no control group that was given a placebo for comparison purposes. (Visually perceive: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15673996?dopt=Abstract) In lieu of a control group, it had two study groups, with one group taking one pill and the other group taking two pills. Both groups showed some amelioration of IBS symptoms. However, it's paramount to recollect that a study for IBS showed that a group that was told it was being given a placebo still showed amendment with IBS.  Either way, non-optically incapacitated, non-randomized studies are of little clinical value.  They definitely don't elevate to the caliber of deserving national pronouncements.

Is Turmeric Really That Helpful?

What is fascinating about Turmeric is that it is a plant that is consumed mostly as an ingredient of local ethnic foods, primarily by natives of India, concretely in Southeast India, where it grows.   It is claimed to have ant-cancer, anti-inflammatory, anti-dementia, anti-infectious, and anti-oxidant properties. With all these health benefits, one would expect that natives of Southeast India would have longer life expectancies.  One would be very erroneous and disappointed as India has one of the lowest rates of life expectancy anywhere in the world. (Optically discern:

http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/download/8112131ec004.pdf?expires=1392400784&id=id&accname=guest&checksum=1561729FC56D11AD485B50AD61D1404A).  Ouch.

Harms of Turmeric

Faithful readers of this blog may recollect a few years back my inditement about the recommendation I received from Michael Roizen, a partner with Dr. Oz on several books, who highly recommended that I consume turmeric for its multiple health benefits, including dementia aversion. (Here's an excerpt from that blog virtually three years ago:

"Dr. Roizen told me that turmeric averts Alzheimer's and is good for encephalon health. Predicated on Dr. Roizen's suggestion that day (and my auditory perception him reiterate the same advice a few days later on the Retirement  Living TV channel), I ingenuously purchased turmeric and commenced to integrate it customarily to my aliment.


Lamentably, the highly staining substance turned my teeth effulgent yellow.  After this disconcerting turn of events, I commenced intensively researching turmeric and discovered two perturbing facts. First, tumeric has little validated science to fortify its use for the designations Dr. Roizen asserted. Second, I discovered that in the absence of an ebony pepper called piperine, turmeric is very poorly absorbed by mundane ingestion and so integrating it to my aliment was an effort in futility, except if turning my teeth yellow was my endgame. (By the way, I had to peregrinate to a dentist to dispense the stain.)"

It was that incident, by the way, that really started me on the path of trying to verify positive statements made about any dietary supplement.

Final (For Now) Word on Turmeric
As an aside, I am not against turmeric, or its derivative curcumin, as an ingredient in repasts.  There is just no authentic good proof that it has a very positive effect on any major human health factor. According to naturalstandard.com, it doesn't get higher than a grade of C, for inconclusive evidence, for any clinical designation.


So once again, Dr. Oz recommends a product that lacks the scientific support he claims. He even goes so far as to give a concrete untested dosage of 500 mg.


Did he just make it up? You ken the answer.

Be More Fit & Healthy | Sport and Fitness blog © 2014. All Rights Reserved | Powered By Blogger | Blogger Templates

Designed by-SpeckyThemes